Exploring Jewish Beliefs About Jesus’ Death

Email from Michael Cohen: “Dear Rabbi Joshua, within Christianity, the crucifixion of Jesus is a central event. I was wondering, do Jews believe that Jesus died on the cross?”

Response from Rabbi Joshua

Shalom Michael, you raise a question that touches on a key difference between Jewish and Christian beliefs. Let’s address this from the Jewish perspective.

Jewish Views on Jesus’ Crucifixion

While Judaism recognizes Jesus as a historical figure, his life and death are not doctrinal components of the Jewish faith. Jewish texts do not discuss the crucifixion of Jesus in detail, as it is not an event of religious significance to Jews.

Jewish Historical Perspectives

From a historical perspective, Jews acknowledge that crucifixion was a common method of execution used by the Roman Empire. Whether Jesus was executed in this manner is a question of history rather than theology for Jews. Therefore, while some Jews may accept that Jesus was crucified as a historical fact, they do not attribute any religious meaning to this event.

Divergence in Religious Narratives

The narrative of Jesus’ death on the cross is a central element of Christian theology, associated with themes of atonement and resurrection. Judaism does not share these beliefs and does not incorporate the crucifixion into its religious narrative.

Conclusion

Michael, while Jews may recognize the crucifixion of Jesus as a historical possibility, they do not attribute to it the theological significance that Christianity does. The story of Jesus, including his death, does not play a role in Jewish theology or practice.

If you have further questions or are interested in learning more about Jewish history and beliefs, please feel free to reach out.

Best regards,

Rabbi Joshua

Jewish Perspective on Christmas

Understanding Jewish Engagement with Christmas

Email from Jonathan Silver: “Dear Rabbi Joshua, with Christmas being such a major holiday in many countries, I was wondering how Jews relate to this holiday. Do Jews believe in or celebrate Christmas?”

Response from Rabbi Joshua

Shalom Jonathan, your question is quite common, especially given the widespread cultural presence of Christmas. Let’s address how Jews typically view this holiday.

Christmas as a Christian Holiday

Christmas is a Christian holiday that celebrates the birth of Jesus Christ. Since Jesus is not a messianic figure in Judaism, Christmas does not hold religious significance for Jews, and they do not celebrate it as a religious holiday.

Jews and Christmas Celebrations

While Jews do not celebrate Christmas, some may participate in secular aspects of the holiday, such as attending a holiday party or enjoying the festive decorations, particularly in countries where Christmas plays a significant cultural role. However, these actions are cultural rather than religious and do not indicate a belief in the religious aspects of the holiday.

Jewish Holidays Around the Christmas Season

Jews have their own holiday season around the same time of year, which includes Hanukkah, also known as the Festival of Lights. Hanukkah celebrates the rededication of the Second Temple in Jerusalem and is marked by lighting menorahs, eating traditional foods, and playing games.

Respect for Religious Diversity

Within the spirit of respect for religious diversity, Jews recognize the importance of Christmas to Christians and often extend good wishes to their Christian friends and neighbors during the holiday season.

Conclusion

Jonathan, while Jews do not believe in or celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday, they may acknowledge and respect the holiday’s place in the lives of those who do celebrate it. Judaism teaches the importance of respecting all religions and the value of coexisting harmoniously with people of different faiths.

If you have more questions about Jewish traditions or interfaith relations, please feel free to reach out.

Kind regards,

Rabbi Joshua